Dear Dwonna:
I’m from Illinois, and I’m graduating with my BA from TXST in December.
My dad and I have had–and still have–a kind of difficult relationship. He was pretty abusive (mostly emotionally but some physical and verbal) when I was a child, but he’s mellowed out, somewhat, in his older age. Still, he can show signs of aggression, like when he choked my dog to the point that my dog’s eyes bulged out. My dad justified choking my dog by saying that my dog had bitten him.
I’m telling you all of this because he wants me to move back to Illinois after I graduate to live with him while I figure out what my next move is going to be. He said I can live with him for free, but I don’t know if I should trade free rent in exchange for living with a man who still shows signs of aggression. Moreover, he’s still emotionally unavailable and avoids any conversations about my turbulent childhood with him and his mother.
What should I do?
Signed,
Michelle
_____
Hi friend,
This is definitely a hard road to navigate. Because this is your father, there’s so much that is there to unpack. Approach the situation hesitantly, and be safe when navigating through this situation. At the end of the day your safety is key. Although he has become better, if you don’t feel safe and secure, then continue to maintain the distance. To protect your peace as well as protecting yourself, if he’s still emotionally unavailable and shows those signs of aggression, then I recommend leaving that situation alone for now. Anyway, I hope this helps, and I hope that you have the most amazing day!
Christian
Hi Michelle,
Thank you for sharing your experience with us, and congratulations on earning your
degree. Don’t forget to soak in your accomplishment, and don’t allow anything to steal
the joy of this moment.
I first want to acknowledge how difficult it can be navigating a relationship with a toxic
parent. Your safety should always be a priority on a mental, emotional, and physical
level. Although your being offered financial convenience with your dad covering the
living expenses, it should not be in exchange for your safety. If the recent aggression
towards your dog is reminding you of your childhood trauma and giving you the inkling
that there has been no change in behavior, it may not be the best decision for you to put
yourself back in such a chaotic environment.
You also mentioned that as he has gotten older that he is a lot more mellow. While this
is a good thing, it does not necessarily mean that he has addressed the behaviors that
caused you harm during your childhood. There is a difference between someone
becoming less aggressive and someone taking accountability for their past
wrongdoings. Your father’s unwillingness to acknowledge your childhood experiences is
something that I believe you should consider when making your decision.
I would suggest exploring other living arrangements before making the decision to move
back home with your dad. These alternatives will more than likely require more financial
responsibility, which, of course, you must consider, but having your own space and
peace of mind is something you should not overlook. I do think that your movement
toward reconciliation should not require you to compromise your own emotional or
physical well-being. You can acknowledge the relationship you have with your father
and appreciate his willingness to support your financially while also recognizing that
maintaining a healthy distance may be what’s best for you.
Rebuilding a relationship takes time, accountability, and mutual effort. Moving forward, I
encourage you to prioritize your safety and personal growth, and remember that you are
allowed to establish boundaries with your family to protect yourself, even when their
intentions may be good.
Signed,
Mikai
EDITOR’S NOTE:
If you or someone you know needs help with an abuse issue, you may contact the Counseling Center on Campus — https://www.counseling.txst.edu/ or call 512-245-2208. If the person seeking help is not a student, they may call 800-799-SAFE, text “begin” to 88788, or go to thehotline.org for help.